OKC VeloCity | Strategic Collaborators: Tribal Nations | VeloCityOKC

Strategic Collaborators: Tribal Nations

By Kyle D. Dean, PhD / Economy / April 13, 2022

First Americans Museum celebrates our shared American history through the collective stories of 39 distinct tribal nations in Oklahoma today. 

Editor's note: This piece was originally written for the IEDC Economic Development Journal. We thought readers might be interested in learning a bit about the Chamber's response to economic development challenges. An edited version of the original is below.

Introduction

There are 39 Native American tribes residing within Oklahoma’s borders that are recognized by the federal government or by the state. With different cultures and economic systems, the tribes were mashed together in what was Indian Country, now Oklahoma. Their tribal governments were eventually abolished, and their cultural and economic institutions were purposely devastated by a near-century of assimilation policies.

The federal government switched course in the late 20th century, pursuing rules and legislation that encouraged tribal self-determination, culminating with the passage of the Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act of 1975 and the Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978. The movement toward tribal sovereignty provided fertile ground for the green shoots of tribal economic development for the first time since the late 19th century. With sovereignty, tribes had the authority to directly control/administer federal programs for tribal citizens allowing them to set their own course for a sustainable economic future.

In 1988, the federal government passed the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act (IGRA) which allowed tribes to compact with states to provide restricted gaming within their jurisdictional areas. Oklahoma voters approved State Question 712 in 2004, authorizing the state to offer a model compact to tribes wishing to provide class 3, Vegas-style gaming within their jurisdictional areas in accordance with IGRA, with operations beginning in 2006. Many tribes were already offering gaming through legal class 2. This new class 3 option provided the tribes a platform to provide more gaming and entertainment services, yielding greater income for tribal purposes, including business diversification and provision of government programs and services.

The benefits from tribal economic development are reaped by the citizens of Oklahoma as well as the tribes.  We can see this in the exclusivity fees collected by the state that grew exponentially in the early years of operations (2006 - 2010), moving to a more steady-state rate in recent times. Compacted gaming revenues grew by an average of 110% from 2006 to 2009. By 2019, the 3-year average annual growth rate of 2.6% implied a maturation of the industry.

Oklahoma is roughly three-fourths covered by tribal jurisdictional areas/reservations. With the exception of Tulsa, most of these areas exist throughout rural portions of the state, which if true to the national trend would be in significant decline owing to urbanization. Rural areas in Oklahoma have ready-made recreation and entertainment bases with tribal gaming. Nineteenth-century removal policies guarantee that tribes will continue to operate within their treaty borders in accordance with IGRA. Tribes can operate gaming properties in other jurisdictions where the law allows.).

Economic Impacts

Tribal economies differ from all other entities in the United States. They incorporate government functions similar to federal and local governments and operate a diverse portfolio of businesses, unlike state and local governments. As such, their impacts are unique. Tribal businesses seek to maximize profits from which they fund other businesses, and most importantly, fund tribal government activities to ensure the long-run sustainability of the tribe. Thus, a full impact assessment must include the impacts from all government and business activities.

There have been a few seminal impact assessments of tribes in Oklahoma in the last ten years, including gaming-specific reports such as (Dean and Robinson 2015) and (Dean and Robinson 2016) and full assessments of all tribal activity ((Dean 2012) and (Dean 2019)) as well as other assessments for individual tribes. The results presented in these reports are useful for understanding the full impact of tribal activity in the state.

Gaming Impact

Tribal Government Gaming is the most significant source of impact for tribes in the state. The Dean and Robinson study of 2016 estimated the total impact of statewide gaming to be $7.2 billion in 2015, supporting 48,942 jobs. Tribal gaming has become an economic base industry, with 41% of the facility visits coming from outside the state.

A large share of the impacts from gaming are felt directly in under-served rural communities due to the compact and federal restrictions requiring operations on tribal trust land within treaty boundaries. Of the total property visits in 2015, 64% occurred in rural Oklahoma communities. This fed employment in these communities with 66% of direct tribal gaming employment occurring in rural Oklahoma. Of these employees, 56.8% were not tribal citizens, emphasizing the link between tribal development and local community employment.

Impact from all Tribal Activity

Dean 2012 and Dean 2019 estimated the full economic impacts of all tribal economic activity for the years 2011 and 2017. In 2011, tribes directly contributed an estimated $5 billion to the Oklahoma economy through business operations, government expenditures, and capital investments. When accounting for multiplier effects due to related industry and household spending, they had a total output impact of $10.8 billion. Tribal direct contribution grew to $7.3 billion, a 42% increase, in 2017 with a total output impact of $12.9 billion. At the same time, total employment impacts grew from 87,714 to 96,177. Direct tribal employment was 51,674 in 2017.

Employment Rankings in Oklahoma

The Oklahoma Department of Commerce (ODOC) provides an annual list of the largest employers in the state of Oklahoma. The Department of Defense (DOD) always tops the list with the most recent estimate of direct employment of 69,500. The second-largest employer is Wal-Mart at 39,000. When it comes to tribes, ODOC does not follow a similar combination methodology to the DOD. Indeed, they do not combine all activities from each tribe, choosing instead to divide tribal employment into component parts. The table below re-ranks employers in the state by combining individual tribal activity. Using this methodology, individual tribes now rank as the 4th, 5th, 7th, 37th, and 123rd largest employers in the state. These estimates are combinations of estimates from ODOC.

Oklahoma Top Employers by # of Employees (1,000 and above)

Rank

Employer

Emp_2021

Emp_2019

1

Department Of Defense (U.S.)

69,500

68,500

2

Wal-Mart

39,000

32,150

3

Amazon/Whole Foods

11,250

2,250

4

Chickasaw Nation

10,600

11,200

5

Choctaw Nation

9,900

9,900

6

Integris Health Inc.

9,650

8,850

7

Cherokee Nation

8,600

8,400

8

Hobby Lobby Store Inc

7,750

6,550

9

Oklahoma State University

7,050

7,150

10

US Postal Service

6,750

6,850

11

Saint Francis Hospital

6,450

6,150

12

Dept. of Veterans Affairs

6,350

7,450

13

OK Dept. of Human Services

6,350

6,350

14

University of Oklahoma Norman

6,050

6,550

37

Muscogee Nation

3,100

3,200

64

Citizen Potawatomi Nation

1,950

2,350

123

Quapaw Nation

1,050

1,050

123

Osage Nation

1,050

1,150

Source: Oklahoma Department of Commerce

By comparison, suppose we use the direct tribal employment estimate from the 2019 all-tribe impact report of 51,674 (2017 data) to rank all tribal activity employment. That would easily make Oklahoma tribes the second largest employer in the state, demonstrating the direct importance of tribal employment; more so when considering the share of tribal employment that occurs in rural areas that would otherwise be experiencing greater declines in employment and population.

With this data as a baseline, the following are case studies involving five tribal nations and how collaborative efforts between each Native American tribe and the local community is helping to spur economic growth in both urban and rural communities.

Conclusion

The changes in U.S. policy in the late 20th century and the liberalization of tribal government gaming allowed tribes in Oklahoma to establish an economic base from which to create a sustainable future for tribal citizens. Currently, tribes are diversifying their businesses into a wide variety of industries from manufacturing to professional services. Their increased economic power has created opportunity for the tribes to provide programs and services for tribal citizens such as workforce training and education, healthcare, home-buying assistance and more, enhancing skills and the quality of life for citizens.

With the increase in tribal economic impact, the economic fates of the state of Oklahoma and the tribes in Oklahoma are becoming more intertwined. This can be seen in the growth in employment and in the employer rankings put forward by the Oklahoma Department of Commerce. This is especially true in rural Oklahoma where tribes employ a greater share of local workers as tribal economic growth pushes against the pressures of rural decline being observed throughout the United States. The Tribes, the State, and Municipalities are occupying the same ground at the same moment in history; and all are providing services to the citizens of Oklahoma, the U.S. and beyond, making Tribal Nations key strategic collaborators in improving economic and community development.

OU Health Banner Ad July 2026